The Chicago Cubs have remained one of the most active teams in ongoing trade discussions, particularly after the setback involving Matthew Boyd’s injury. While the club has been performing at a high level lately, baseball history reminds supporters that early-season success does not guarantee postseason achievement.
With that perspective in mind, front-office decision-makers may need to pursue a significant acquisition to strengthen their pitching staff and avoid falling into the trap of relying solely on current starters.
Over the past week and a half, Chicago has posted an impressive 8-2 record, demonstrating strong momentum. However, they have not pulled away decisively in the standings, as divisional opponents like the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers have also struggled. At the same time, the Cubs continue to battle the Atlanta Braves for one of the top records across Major League Baseball, highlighting how competitive the landscape remains.
FanSided contributor Mark Powell recently outlined a potential blockbuster deal that could address Chicago’s rotation concerns. In the proposal, the Cubs would send three promising prospects to the Miami Marlins in return for frontline starter Sandy Alcantara, who has quickly become one of the most prominent available arms this season.
The players heading to Miami in this scenario would include shortstop and second baseman Jefferson Rojas, right-hander Kaleb Wing, and right-hander Grant Kipp. This package represents a notable investment in young talent, but it could provide the Cubs with immediate help at a critical position.
Chicago already shares a positive trading history with the Marlins. Earlier this offseason, the Cubs brought in Edward Cabrera, who has quietly become a reliable contributor in the starting rotation. That prior connection could help facilitate smoother negotiations if Miami decides to move their former ace.
Currently, the Cubs are operating with a four-man rotation featuring Jameson Taillon, Colin Rea, Shota Imanaga, and Cabrera. Securing another high-caliber starter would add much-needed depth and innings, especially given the team’s recent injury challenges. Alcantara, who has already logged 51.2 innings this year, fits the profile of a durable workhorse capable of making a major impact down the stretch.
Powell explains the rationale behind pursuing such a move:
“While adding Cabrera was some much-needed depth, what the Cubs couldn’t account for was injuries to Horton, Steele and Matthew Boyd. Some of those injuries, particularly to the latter two, are long term. So if the Cubs are going to reach their ultimate goal this season — and that’s to win a World Series — they need to swing for the fences.”
Alcantara signed a five-year, $56 million extension several seasons ago, but his impending free agency adds another layer of appeal for potential suitors. Teams acquiring him would gain not only his services for the remainder of this campaign but also the chance to evaluate him before a possible long-term commitment or departure.
This season across eight starts, the right-hander owns a 4.01 ERA. Known as a true innings-eater, he has adapted his approach following various workload adjustments. In each of his last four complete seasons, Alcantara made at least 28 starts, and current indicators suggest he remains on track to deliver similar durability.
Looking at the bigger picture, Alcantara boasts a 3.67 ERA over 1,127 innings across his nine-year Major League Baseball career. His standout 2022 campaign earned him the National League Cy Young Award, underscoring his proven ability to dominate when healthy and locked in.
As trade rumors continue to swirl around virtually every available starting pitcher, the Cubs appear destined to stay involved in those conversations. Unless the organization accelerates the promotion of internal pitching prospects, external additions through the marketplace could prove essential for sustaining their contention hopes through the demanding months ahead.
A deal for a pitcher of Alcantara’s pedigree might represent exactly the kind of bold step needed to position the franchise for a deep October run.
