The New York Yankees appear willing to move on from third baseman Ryan McMahon this offseason, but only under specific conditions that would strengthen their infield.
According to FanSided reporter Pat Ragazzo, the club is open to dealing the former All-Star if they can acquire another infielder in return.
The development arrives just days after conflicting signals that general manager Brian Cashman might prefer to keep McMahon following public praise for the player.
In his latest report, Ragazzo wrote: “The Yankees are open to trading McMahon if they acquire another infielder, which they’re currently in the market for, as a league source told FanSided.
“The Yankees are looking for infield help and upgrades at the third base position after the poor year that McMahon had in the Bronx. This should come as no surprise, since the Yankees are trying to break their 17-year World Series title drought.”
Whether the desired return would be an established major leaguer or a prospect remains unclear, yet the priority is clear: New York wants infield reinforcement in any McMahon trade.
The organization acquired the left-handed hitter from the Colorado Rockies in 2025, expecting his defensive reliability at the hot corner to pair with enough offense.
Instead, power production has declined sharply. While his glove remains an asset, the bat has become a clear liability.
During the 2026 season, McMahon appeared in 124 games and finished with a 0.0 bWAR, 11 home runs, and a 76 OPS+.
Those numbers sit well below league average and underscore why an upgrade at third base has surfaced as a priority. Since arriving in the Bronx, he has managed only 37 extra-base hits across 178 games.
With one year remaining on his six-year, $70 million contract, the remaining salary complicates any potential deal.
Finding a trade partner willing to absorb that money while parting with useful infield talent may prove challenging, especially given the limited offensive output.
Even so, the Yankees’ stated openness to a move reflects a broader offseason approach centered on improving the roster around a championship core.
External options at third base have drawn interest, and the willingness to part with McMahon suggests the front office is prepared to absorb financial costs if the right infield piece becomes available.
Whether that leads to an actual trade or simply serves as leverage remains to be seen, but the latest reporting makes plain that McMahon’s future in New York is no longer guaranteed.



