The Philadelphia Phillies enter Tuesday night’s matchup against the St. Louis Cardinals looking to build on their series-opening win, with ace Christopher Sanchez scheduled to take the mound.
Hours before first pitch in St. Louis, the club released its lineup, and the return of Alec Bohm has once again become a focal point of discussion among fans.
After sitting out Monday’s contest, Bohm finds himself back in the starting nine. Manager Don Mattingly has slotted the veteran into the eighth spot in the order while assigning him first base duties, a configuration that mirrors the team’s approach from Sunday.
The full batting order places Kyle Schwarber in the designated hitter role, followed by Trea Turner, Bryce Harper, Luis Arraez, J.T. Realmuto, Bryson Stott, Brandon Marsh, Bohm, and Johan Rojas in center field.
The decision has drawn sharp reactions across social media. Many supporters have voiced frustration, questioning why Bohm continues to occupy a regular role when his production has lagged.
Comments range from calls to limit him to pinch-hitting duties to suggestions that a more permanent roster move could be warranted before the season ends. Some worry that accommodating Bohm at first base places unnecessary strain on Harper’s defensive responsibilities and overall availability.
There is a counterpoint worth considering. The Phillies lack an obvious, markedly superior everyday alternative at the position, and Bohm has demonstrated the durability to handle a full slate of games. That reliability carries value even during an uneven stretch at the plate.
Statistically, the 2026 season has been a difficult one for Bohm. Through 115 games he is hitting .227 with 13 home runs and 63 runs batted in. His OPS+ sits at 73, a clear drop from his career .273 batting average and a reflection of the struggles that have defined this campaign.
With free agency approaching after the year, the downturn has done little to strengthen his market standing; a negative WAR further underscores the challenges.
As the Phillies chase another series victory under the Gateway Arch, the conversation around Bohm is unlikely to quiet.
Whether the current arrangement represents a short-term adjustment or a longer-term statement of trust remains to be seen on the field.
Fans will be watching closely to see if the veteran can deliver the kind of contribution that silences the growing skepticism.
