ESPN analyst Mina Kimes dismissed Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen from the NFL MVP conversation this week, saying he is playing worse than last season despite the team’s 8-1 start.
“Josh Allen, we haven’t spent much time talking about,” Kimes said on The Mina Kimes Show on Tuesday. “Like I said, I think he’s asked to do a lot, but he’s obviously playing worse than he did last year, to my eyes, so I just don’t see it personally.”
Allen, the 2024 NFL MVP, has guided the Bills to their best start since 1991. Buffalo is 8-1 after Sunday’s 31-12 win over the New York Jets and leads the AFC East.
Through nine games, Allen has completed 167 of 257 passes for 2,223 yards, 13 touchdowns and seven interceptions. His completion percentage stands at 65.0 percent, down from 69.3 percent in 2025 when he finished with 3,668 yards, 25 touchdowns and 10 interceptions.
At his current pace, Allen is on track for roughly 4,200 passing yards and 25 touchdown passes, matching or exceeding last season’s totals. He is also projected for about 13 interceptions.
His rushing numbers have improved. Allen has 66 carries for 290 yards and 11 touchdowns this year. In 2025 he had 112 carries for 579 yards and 14 scores. He is on pace for about 21 rushing touchdowns.
“Josh Allen is on pace for 25 pass TDs and 21 rush TDs,” NFL analyst Michael F. Florio wrote on his official X account on Tuesday. “There’s never been a 20-20 season.”
Allen’s 24 total touchdowns this season already surpass the season totals of 15 NFL teams.
On Sunday against the Jets, Allen’s 1-yard rushing touchdown in the first half marked his 323rd career total touchdown. The score moved him past Peyton Manning’s 322 total touchdowns in his first 10 seasons. Allen reached the mark nine games into his ninth season.
“Josh Allen rushes for the touchdown, marking his 323rd career total touchdown,” Buffalo Bills PR wrote on its official X account on Sunday. “Allen, nine games into his ninth season, has surpassed Peyton Manning (322) for the most total TDs all-time by a player in their first 10 seasons.”
Allen added another rushing touchdown and a passing score later in the game, pushing his career total to 325. He entered the contest with 232 career passing touchdowns and 88 rushing scores.
“HISTORY: Bills QB Josh Allen has officially set the NFL record for the most total touchdowns by a quarterback through his first 10 seasons, surpassing Patrick Mahomes and Peyton Manning,” ML Football wrote on its official X account on Sunday. “Allen accomplished the historic feat in just NINE seasons. FIRST-BALLOT HALL OF FAMER.”
Allen has accounted for multiple touchdowns in eight of nine games this season. The Bills average 31.9 points per game, the highest mark in the NFL, and sit at 31.9 points for and 22.1 allowed.
Buffalo next hosts the Miami Dolphins on Sunday. The team has not lost since a Week 4 defeat to New England and has won five straight.
Allen’s dual-threat production continues to drive the offense even as wide receiver injuries and running back James Cook’s earlier fumbles limited support. Cook has since stabilized, and the Bills rank second in the league in rushing yards per game at 152.7.
Kimes’ comments came during a discussion of midseason MVP candidates with ESPN’s Ben Solak. She has previously noted the pressure on Buffalo’s front office to build around Allen after his contract extension.
The Bills’ 8-1 record and Allen’s historic scoring pace stand in contrast to the analyst’s assessment. No quarterback has ever posted a 20-20 season in passing and rushing touchdowns.



