The Chicago Cubs’ midseason bet on David Peterson looked like a calculated gamble when they acquired the left-hander from the Mets on June 25, but by season’s end it had become one of the more quietly effective moves of their 2026 campaign.
With the rotation thinned by injuries, the Cubs sent prospect Cole Mathis to New York for the 30-year-old southpaw, who had posted a 6.09 ERA in 16 appearances with the Mets.
Peterson’s underlying numbers remained closer to his established form as a ground-ball pitcher, yet a .350 batting average on balls in play had inflated his results in Queens. Chicago’s elite infield defense offered a logical antidote, and Peterson largely rewarded the faith.
After one rough outing early in his Cubs tenure, he settled in and delivered a 3.70 ERA across 80 1/3 innings in 16 games, 15 of them starts.
From that point forward he worked to a 2.66 ERA over 71 innings, striking out hitters at a slightly higher rate while continuing to induce ground balls at a clip above 50 percent.
The improvement aligned with his track record from 2022 through 2025, when he had logged a 4.00 ERA with a strikeout per inning and a ground-ball rate of 52.5 percent.
Peterson’s late-season form helped stabilize a rotation that had been searching for reliable innings, and he finished the year as a free agent after declining to return.
Now the Colorado Rockies have emerged as a reported suitor.
According to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, Peterson is among the free-agent starters drawing interest from Colorado, which has already added Luis Castillo and Davis Martin via trade with the White Sox.
Jeff Passan of ESPN has described the Rockies as aggressive in pursuing multi-year deals for starters, offering contracts that account for the challenges of pitching at Coors Field.
Peterson’s Colorado roots—he spent his teenage years in the state and attended high school roughly 20 miles from the ballpark—could make the pitch more appealing than it would be for many others.
His career-long ground-ball tendencies also mesh with the park’s spacious outfield and the Rockies’ defensive alignment at the infield corners and shortstop.
For the Cubs, the interest underscores how effectively Peterson performed after the trade. What began as a deadline depth acquisition evolved into a stretch of quality starts that validated the change of scenery.
Whether Chicago attempts to re-sign him or watches him land elsewhere, his 2026 performance with the club stands as evidence that the midseason acquisition delivered more than short-term innings.
The lefty’s ability to rebound behind a strong defense turned a struggling veteran into a functional rotation piece, and that body of work now shapes his free-agent market.



